Underrated Qualities to Look for When Hiring CSMs ft. Sample Interview Questions

Key metrics such as retention and growth of ARR is not a skill or quality the CSM has, but the result of many intangible qualities that are a big differentiator between an average CSM and an extremely talented CSM. One that will bring the best results to your team and drive growth.

When looking to hire CSM candidates and we look at their CVs, we will always look for data points that are measurable and give us an indication of how strong the candidate is, for example: years of work experience, size of portfolios the CSM managed, accounts the CSM worked with in the past, retention and growth of net ARR, size and type of accounts the CSM has worked with, among other things.

However, key metrics such as retention and growth of ARR is not a skill or quality the CSM has, but the result of many intangible qualities that are a big differentiator between an average CSM and an extremely talented CSM. One that will bring the best results to your team and drive growth.

Before diving into the qualities we should look for, we first have to understand the roles and responsibilities of a CSM and the value they bring to B2B SaaS companies.

What Roles and Responsibilities Does a Customer Success Manager Have?

With technology leading today’s global economy, the SaaS industry is projected to amount at an astonishing $307B at an 11.7% compound annual growth rate (CAGR). When the SaaS model initially formed, companies realized that having a good product that sells wasn’t enough to grow the business. They soon realized that in order to grow their business they would need to retain their existing clients, and with time, they understood that by retaining their clients they wouldn’t only be able to maintain a constant cash flow, but drive growth through expansion revenue. 

The person sitting in the driver’s seat when it comes to customer retention and growth is the Customer Success Manager. In B2B SaaS, the CSM is in charge of: 

  • Onboarding the customer
  • Identifying the reasons why a customer is using their product
  • Showcase and increase the added value of the product
  • Communicate the needs and wants of customers to different teams within the company i.e. product, sales, customer service, etc.
  • Build relationships
  • Lead the customer to achieve their objectives
  • Retain and grow their book of business

CSM Job Description

Clearly, the CSM is accountable and responsible for many things that are highly important for the company. 

At a high-level, when I’m looking to hire a CSM, I make sure that the most important (and more obvious) points are covered such as customer onboarding, strategic advising, renewals, showcasing value to customers, relationship building, high EQ, success plans, etc. 

However, I also like to mention the responsibilities that are not necessarily only related to the customer but are critical to achieve business growth such as communication between the product team and the customer, collaborating with the marketing team to build content, collaborating with sales to achieve value-based account growth, ability to use internal resources (support, product, R&D) to push things forward, among others. 

Qualities to Look for in a Customer Success Manager

Underrated Qualities to Look for in a CSM

Most hiring managers look for CSM candidates that will be capable of building successful relationships with their customers and drive value-based retention and growth. There are two ways you can determine if a CSM candidate has these qualities, you can look at their CV to read more about the type of customers they’ve worked with, how big was the account portfolio, did they achieve any growth, what companies did they work at (are the companies industry leaders/growing companies)—in short, measurable qualities that can be easily identified. 

The other set of qualities are harder to pick up on, and more qualitative than quantitative in nature. Without these qualities, CSMs are missing a big part of the equation that leads to the most important result for CS organizations, customer renewals, and ultimately, growth. 

In no particular order, these are some of the most underrated, yet most important, qualities that hiring managers should look for in CSMs:

  1. Growth Mindset: This will go a long way, since a CSM with a growth mindset will not only look to always improve, but they will take accountability for their mistakes, learn from them and share them with the organization so everyone around them can improve.
  1. Team player: It’s ok to look for sharks, however, sharks that are also team players will share their success methods with the rest of your team and will improve your team’s performance overall.
  1. High Emotional Intelligence (EQ): Would the candidate be able to find a common ground between themselves and their customers? Finding that human connection will slowly remove the friction within a customer-vendor relationship and help turn it into a meaningful and strong relationship. This quality will also be important to understand if the candidate will be able to get along with coworkers and use their social skills to connect with other teams/departments.
  1. Open Minded/Open to New Perspectives: Having lived in and visited many different countries, this is a trait I can personally speak to the importance of. Regardless of where a customer is from, it’s important to be able to relate to them in a way that is both personal and professional. Like Nelson Mandela said; “If you talk to a man in a language he understands, that goes to his head. If you talk to him in his own language, that goes to his heart.”
  1. Strategic Mindset: This quality is critical to understand if the candidate is capable of overcoming difficult scenarios, creating success plans that go hand-in-hand with the customer’s desired outcomes and building a growth strategy that delivers value to the customer.
  1. Technical understanding/Industry knowledge: The more a CSM knows about how their product works and what is happening in their industry, the easier it will be for them to identify the needs of their customers and provide the right solution for them by providing them with the correct context and use-case.

These qualities are a “must-have” for me that are not usually mentioned within the job description, or are missed because hiring managers may be too focused on the output, without paying attention to the inputs that ultimately lead to the successful results.

Questions to Ask During A CSM Interview to Uncover Underrated Qualities

So the candidate has passed the screening stage, now it’s time to identify if they have any of those critical skills mentioned in this article. Here are some questions that can help you, the hiring manager, identify those qualities:

Growth Mindset

Ask the candidate to share their experience with a difficult situation that led to a learning experience. Here’s what to look for:

  • What did the candidate learn from this experience?
  • What did the candidate do and how did they improve themselves because of this difficult experience?

Team player

This one is easier to identify. Ask questions along the lines of how involved he/she was with team projects, mentoring team members, sharing knowledge, experiences, etc.

High EQ

Pay attention to the personality of the candidate. Do they seem candid? Are they excited about questions asked during the interview? Is the candidate making the atmosphere tense or do you feel an easy-going vibe? When talking about a difficult situation, does the candidate show empathy or interest for the other side’s position? Here are some examples:

  • Tell me about a difficult situation with a client where your relationship with them helped ease the situation and allowed you to reach a positive outcome?
  • Give them a complex scenario that allows them to share their approach, such as the product not working and the customer asking for credits/compensation. Note: This one is tricky because it not only involves EQ but also professionalism and experience in the field.

Open Minded/Open to New Perspectives

Ask them about their life experience. What are their hobbies outside of work? Have they had the opportunity to work with customers that were outside their region? If so, how did they manage to narrow down the cultural bridge?

Strategic Mindset

This one is one of my favourites. I typically ask candidates to tell me about their most challenging accounts and how they managed to retain and grow them. Moving forward, I would give them a home assignment that would require them to build a strategy to reach the best possible outcome, such as, how would you approach the renewal of a customer that is not fully convinced, or a customer whose champion has recently changed? The goal is to understand their reasoning and ability to connect the dots to overcome any situation that is presented to them.

Technical Understanding/Industry Knowledge

Some hiring managers like to ask specific technical questions about their product. However, this is missing the point, seeing as what you actually want to identify is if they know the added value of your product within the industry, not how a specific feature works. Asking the candidates they would recommend your product to customers and what added value can they gain from it will give you a clear picture of their understanding of the technology your product offers and how impactful it is to the industry ecosystem.

When hiring CSMs, we always want to hire the ones that have achieved great results when it comes to customer retention and growth, but remember, it’s not the destination that matters most, but what led them to achieve those results.

High-performance CSMs are not always equipped with these qualities, but CSMs that do have these qualities will definitely become high-performers and make everyone on your team (including yourself) improve as a whole.

In Vitally's latest video series, 17 Questions on the Future of Customer Success, we've chatted with some of the best Customer Success Managers out there on how they think about Customer Success and its evolving role, what makes their CS org world-class, and a whole lot more. You can check out those interviews here:

Want to increase CSM outputs without increasing headcount? Vitally's world-class Customer Success platform empowers Customer Success teams at B2B SaaS companies to 10x CSM efficiency by centralizing and contextualizing customer data from tools across your tech stack, so CSMs can create best-in-class Customer Experiences at scale. Learn how we can help your team do the same when you request a personalized demo today.

Here's what you should read next...

Discover the Customer Success resources you need to supercharge your book of business.

Get started with Vitally today

Schedule a personalized demo today.

Thank you!

We have received your request and will process it as soon as possible.

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.